McGuire Law Offices Serving Clearwater, Pinellas County and Tampa Bay Florida

Pinellas County divorce, bankruptcy, personal injury and criminal law

  • Home
  • Attorney Profiles
    • John F. McGuire Esquire
    • Gino A. Megna, Esquire
    • Larry C. Hoffman, Esquire
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury Cases
    • Family Law
      • Restrictions on Relocation
      • Domestic Violence
      • Child Custody
      • Prenuptial
      • Annulment
      • Contempt
      • Alimony
      • Divorce
      • Attorney Fees
    • Criminal Law
      • DUI
      • Felony of all types including capital crimes
      • Misdemeanors
      • Expunging
    • Traffic Tickets
      • Fix Your Traffic Ticket for $69
    • Estate Planning
    • Bankruptcy
  • Support Our Troops
  • Directions
  • Legal Opinionator
  • Contact
  • T
  • FB
You are here: Home / Child Custody / Rapist Rights in Child Custody Cases

Rapist Rights in Child Custody Cases

January 24, 2019 By John McGuire

Yes, you read the title correctly.  Rapists, believe it or not, have legal rights when it comes to the seeking custody of the child born from the sexual assault.  In 31 states, a rapist can sue the victim for custodial rights but in none of those states does the victim have a right to sue the perpetrator for child support.

According to Snopes, “No aspect of that preface suggested that victims of rape “cannot” seek child support, only that laws in some states are structured in a manner that effectively discourage or present difficult-to-surmount barriers to such action.

The primary claim, that 31 states allow a rapist to sue a victim for custody and visitation rights, is far murkier. Unrelated actions decided upon by the Supreme Court in the mid-1990s have upheld state authority over federal authority in cases pertaining to rape.

A possible source for the “31 states” assertion appears to be a 31 August 2012 item published by The Atlantic titled “31 States Allow Rapists Custody and Visitation Rights.” That piece referenced a 2010 law journal article about what might be called a legal loophole, while observing that between 2010 and 2012, several states had amended their laws.”

However, attention to the outrage has compelled some states to take a second look and pass legislation that provides some protection for the victims.  “Seven states don’t have any laws preventing a rapist from claiming parental rights, but that’s not to say that these states are oblivious to the issue. Maryland, for one, has been working for years to pass a law that would allow a rape victim to terminate her attacker’s parental rights.

Forty-three other states and the District of Columbia have legislation that offers at least some protection to prevent rape victims from facing their attackers over parental rights; eight of those laws were just adopted in 2016.”

In considering this issue, it’s important to remember that it is not there have been laws enacted to offer legal rights to rapists.  What has happened is that legal loopholes and legal minutiae allow for this to happen.  Once we’re aware of it though is when something needs to be done to correct it.

Past Commentary

  • Military Court Upholds Convicts of Sailor for Failure to Disclose HIV Status to Sexual Partners
  • Opioid Training Mandatory for Docs, Dentists. So Why Did 25% Choose Not to Do It?
  • Florida Criminal Justice Reform May Happen This Year
  • Mold in Military Base Housing is a Problem in Tampa, Across the Country
  • Affair Sours, Mistress Sues, Wife Threatens Divorce-the Life and Times of Baseball Star Miguel Cabrera
  • 30 Years in Prison for a Crime He Didn’t Commit
  • Wrongful Arrests and What You Can Do About It
  • To Reveal or Not to Reveal-That is the Question with Sebring Mass Shooting and Marsy’s Law
  • Rapist Rights in Child Custody Cases
  • Football Coach Fired After Praying After a Game, Supremes Decline to Get Involved
  • “Fake News” and Our Present Situation
  • Entrapment Defense in Florida
  • No Justice for Military Vets Supreme Court Says
  • Suicide and Our Skyway Bridge
  • In Florida Divorce Are Pets People or Property?
  • Opioid Lawsuit Dismissed in Connecticut
  • R. Kelly and the Difficulty of Prevailing in Sex Abuse Cases
  • Employee Rights in Florida and the McDonald’s Debacle
  • Our First Responders Need Our Help
  • Happy New Year 2019!
  • Happy New Year-Party Responsibly So You Can Enjoy 2019
  • Priests, AIDS, and the Abuse Crisis
  • Manufacturers of Flame Retardant Products Subject of Class Action Lawsuit
  • Ancestry and 23andMe Selling Your DNA Data to Big Pharmaceutical Companies
  • Is There a Mental Health Problem in the Sheriff’s Office?
  • North Florida Murder Mystery Goes to Trial 18 Years Later
  • MADD Vigil Highlights Hillsborough’s Problem with DUI Fatalities
  • All Children’s Hospital Situation Goes from Bad to Worse
  • In Pinellas Murder Trial, the Expert is the Controversy
  • “Baby It’s Cold Outside” Sexist or Innocent?
  • Florida Simplified Dissolution of Marriage-Is it Right for You?
  • Marlboro Goes to Pot
  • 11 Most Dangerous Tampa Bay Intersections for Bikes
  • We Have a Warrant for Your Arrest
  • Why Are Children Dying at All Children’s Hospital?

More Opinionator by John McGuire Esq.

Search

We are located in Clearwater, Florida

Click

John McGuire Law Offices
1173 N.E. Cleveland Street
Clearwater, FL 33755

Phone: 727-446-7659
FAX: 727-446-0905

Get Directions

Contact us for a complementary consultation

Click to contact us

Contact Us

Support Our Troops

Click to contact us

How you can help

Million Dollar Advocates Forum

Copyright © 2019 · McGuire Law Offices · Log in
Disclaimer