McGuire Megna Attorneys, An Association of Professionals


DUI Law Firm FL

If you are arrested for a DUI, it’s serious. Florida laws are tough on those driving under the influence of alcohol, chemicals including prescription drugs, or illegal drugs. Driving or actual physical control of a vehicle while impaired by alcoholic beverages, chemicals, or controlled substances can result in various charges. These offenses vary in severity of punishment, but, except for commercial vehicle cases, require proof that the accused: drove or was in actual physical control of a vehicle; was under the influence of an alcoholic beverage, a chemical substance listed in Florida Statutes, Section 877.111, or a controlled substance listed in Florida Statutes, Chapter 893; was impaired or had a blood or breath alcohol level of .08 or higher. Such conduct is unlawful even on private property.

Usually, the offense involves the operation of some kind of motorized vehicle. It may, however, involve the operation of other modes of transportation such as bicycles and scooters. It may be committed in or on any device used to transport a person or property on a highway, except for those used exclusively on stationary rails or tracks. However, the Implied Consent Law, which establishes procedures for securing and testing samples, applies only to “motor vehicles”.

Typically, an officer or another witness sees the driving or the defendant’s statements may prove the driving. When that is not true, the circumstantial evidence rule applies. Thus, in Davis v. State, for example, the court acquitted the defendant where the evidence failed to overcome his testimony and other proof that he was only a passenger in the car. The court reached the same result in Lukas v. State, where there was no direct evidence of driving or actual physical control and the circumstantial evidence failed to exclude every reasonable hypothesis of innocence. The court came to a contrary conclusion in West v. State, in a DUI manslaughter based solely on the State’s expert testimony.

Circumstantial evidence of driving is often necessary where there is an accident involving only one person or several people who are so incapacitated that they are unable to identify the drivers. Proof of actual physical control may be unavailable in such cases because the defendant was not seen in control of the car, the vehicle could not reasonably be operated, or the offense was one usually requiring proof of driving, such as DUI Manslaughter.

Records Sealed/Expunged

Though some legislatures have adopted statutes dealing with the use, dissemination and expungement of arrest records, the question here is whether there is a constitutional right to such expungement when the arrest violated the Fourth Amendment. Some cases have held that there is as part of the constitutional right to privacy, but the more recent cases have ruled otherwise on the strength of Paul v. Davis, holding that this penumbral right has to do only with “matters relating to marriage, procreation, contraception, family relationships, and child rearing and education.”

Some authority is to be found to the effect that the expungement remedy can be grounded on the Fourth Amendment, but while dictum in some cases would suggest that an arrest without probable cause is per se a basis for expungement, the decisions do not support that proposition. Typically, expungement has occurred or been recognized as potential relief where there was a Fourth Amendment violation of an egregious nature. In any event, a balancing process is called for, which suggests that total expungement (as contrasted to limits on use) will be inappropriate when some legitimate future use could be made of the record.



Personal Service, Prompt Attention, Experience and Expertise.

John McGuire’s commitment is to provide you with the prompt, personal attention you deserve at every stage of representation. We take the time to listen to your concerns and provide you with the advice you need to proceed in the right direction, and we keep you informed as your case develops.

Want to sound smart with your friends?

If we don’t win, you don’t pay a penny. When tragedy strikes, our Personal Injury Law Firm is here to help you. Get a risk-free consultation today.

Frequently Asked Questions

McGuire Law Offices is a law firm that specializes in bankruptcy law. The firm’s website features a comprehensive FAQ section that provides answers to common questions about the bankruptcy process. The FAQ section is organized by topic, making it easy for clients to find the information they need. The answers provided are detailed and informative, and are written in plain language that is easy for clients to understand. This section of the website is a valuable resource for clients who may be considering bankruptcy and want to learn more about the process.

What is the difference between a felony and a misdemeanor?

Felonies are more serious crimes than misdemeanors and carry more severe penalties, including longer prison sentences and larger fines.

What are my rights if I am

If you are arrested, you have the right to remain silent and the right to an attorney. You should exercise these rights and contact an experienced criminal defense attorney as soon as possible.

What is plea bargaining and should I consider it?

Plea bargaining is the process of negotiating a plea deal with the prosecutor in exchange for a reduced sentence or charge. Whether you should consider a plea deal will depend on the specific circumstances of your case and your goals.

What is a criminal record and how can it affect me?

A criminal record is a record of your criminal history, including any arrests and convictions. A criminal record can have a significant impact on your ability to find employment, secure housing, and obtain loans.

Scroll to Top